This domain may be for sale. Click here to inquire
God.co.uk
← What is significant about the parallels between 'Bodys' and 'Souls' by Car Seat Headrest?

Hinduism perspective

What is significant about the parallels between 'Bodys' and 'Souls' by Car Seat Headrest?

The Advaita Vedanta teaching that the individual self (atman) and the universal consciousness (Brahman) are not ultimately separate finds a strange and striking echo in the structural relationship between these two Car Seat Headrest songs. "Bodys" and "Souls" are companion pieces from the 2020 album Making a Door Less Open, and their mirroring, their deliberate pairing of physical and metaphysical language, resonates deeply with one of Hinduism's oldest preoccupations: the relationship between the gross material body (sthula sharira) and the subtler, inner self that inhabits and animates it.

In Hindu thought, the human person is not simply a body that happens to have a soul tucked inside it. The philosophical tradition, particularly as developed in the Upanishads, describes multiple layers of selfhood, often called the koshas or sheaths. There is the physical body, then the vital energy body, then the mental body, then the layer of wisdom, and finally the bliss body, with pure consciousness understood as the ground beneath all of them. The two songs mirror this complexity rather than presenting body and soul as opposites that war against each other. "Bodys" is ecstatic, urgent, saturated with physical sensation and collective energy, while "Souls" turns inward, quieter, more uncertain. But crucially, neither is presented as superior. In Vedantic terms, to dismiss the body as merely illusory or sinful would itself be a form of error. The world of form, maya, is not straightforwardly false; it is real at its own level of experience, even if it is not the final word.

The tension the songs explore, between the intoxicating reality of physical existence and the longing to understand what lies beneath it, maps closely onto what Hindu practitioners have wrestled with for centuries. The Bhagavad Gita, perhaps the most widely read of all Hindu texts, begins with exactly this crisis: Arjuna on the battlefield, overwhelmed by the physical and emotional stakes of his situation, and Krishna drawing him towards a deeper understanding of what he actually is. Krishna's teaching is not that the body is irrelevant. It is that mistaking the body for the whole of oneself is the source of suffering. The person who is genuinely disturbed by the question these songs raise, who has felt the inadequacy of pure physicalism but also feels that purely spiritual frameworks leave something essential out, is standing in very good company within Hindu tradition.

Bhakti traditions add another dimension worth considering. In devotional Hinduism, the body is not an obstacle to spiritual life but potentially its very vehicle. Saints like Mirabai and Kabir wrote poetry saturated with physical longing precisely to describe their yearning for the divine. The body's capacity to feel, to ache, to reach toward something it cannot quite name, is treated as spiritually instructive rather than spiritually suspect. The pairing of "Bodys" and "Souls" does something similar: neither song resolves the tension by cancelling out the other. They stand together on the same record, in the same catalogue, suggesting that the person who dances in a crowd and the person who sits alone wondering what any of it means are not two different people but the same person at different moments of a single ongoing inquiry.

If you are sitting with these songs and finding them philosophically uncomfortable, Hinduism would likely say that discomfort is precisely the point. The Upanishads describe a process called viveka, discernment, as a central spiritual practice: learning to distinguish between what is permanent and what is passing, between awareness itself and the objects that arise within it. The songs do not answer this question. They dramatise it. And in doing so they perform, perhaps unintentionally, something very close to what the tradition calls neti neti, "not this, not this", the practice of negating each limited identity, body or soul, physical or metaphysical, until something that cannot be negated begins to become visible. For anyone finding that intellectually or emotionally live, Hindu philosophy does not offer a quick resolution. It offers a whole life's worth of practice for sitting with exactly that question.

Did this help?

Other perspectives on this question

How this was written: answers on this site are written by artificial intelligence, drawing on the published teaching, scripture and scholarship of each tradition, and a person reads and approves every one before it appears here. They explain what a tradition holds rather than argue that it is right.

They are shared for reflection and are not a substitute for professional religious, medical, legal or mental-health advice. If we have misrepresented your tradition, please tell us and we will put it right, or read more about how we work.

If you are struggling or in distress, you are not alone. In the UK you can call Samaritans free on 116 123 any time, or text SHOUT to 85258. If you are in immediate danger, call 999.